With tourism shattered by the pandemic, critics say yet another cruise ship dock is the last thing that Mexico’s Caribbean island of Cozumel needs. But since last June, not a single cruise ship has disembarked passengers there.
Environmental groups also are objecting.
“The new proposal to build the fourth cruise ship dock on Cozumel will destroy the most important project to regenerate coral” on the island, the Global Coral Reef Alliance said in a statement.
The company behind the roughly $25 million project says the cruise industry is expected to grow and it already brings in $480 million per year for Mexico.
The location for the new dock was chosen “in order not to affect coral reefs,” the proposal says. “This was backed up by field work on the sea floor, which no presence of coral reef structures.”
Activists say there is coral there. While they acknowledge the area’s reefs have been ravaged by years of human activity and hurricanes, they say there have years of efforts by volunteer divers to transplant small chunks of living coral anchored to seabed structures to grow new reefs. Thousands of corals have been transplanted so far.
The issue is a difficult one. Tourism accounts for 87% of economic activity in the state of Quintana Roo, where Cozumel is. The state lost tens of thousands of tourism jobs because of the
pandemic, and only some have come back so far.
But according to a Change.org petition that has gained over 38,000 signatures so far, “There are enough docking positions for the total number of cruise ships that arrived in Cozumel prior to the pandemic, and this number is not going to increase but, on the contrary, it will decrease once the pandemic is coming to an end.”
German Mendez, a biologist who founded the Cozumel Coral Reef Restoration Program, said the previous three cruise ship docks built since 1994 destroyed coral that the island was once famous for, and that a fourth isn’t needed.
“There are already too many,” Mendez said. “As it is, there can be nine ships a day, and with new dock it would be 11.”
“The island doesn’t have enough capacity for 120,000 inhabitants and 90,000 cruise ship passengers per day,” he said. “There is only one water treatment plant on Cozumel and only half the island is connected to the system.”
